U.S. gov't shutdown near as House votes to delay Obamacare
By 신현희Published : Sept. 29, 2013 - 20:23
The U.S. government hurtled toward a partial shutdown for the first time in 17 years as Congress deadlocked over Republicans' insistence on delaying the 2010 health-care law.
The House voted 231-192 just after midnight today to stop many of the Affordable Care Act's central provisions for one year and tie that to an extension of government funding through Dec. 15. Senate Democrats said they will reject the plan, and President Barack Obama said he would veto it.
"I've been elected to fight for the people back home, wherever that takes us," said North Carolina Republican Mark Meadows. He called the amendment a compromise because it delayed the health-care law, widely referred to as Obamacare, instead of repealing it.
The past day's developments raised the prospect of the first government shutdown since 1996, which would put as many as 800,000 federal employees out of work starting Tuesday, Oct. 1.
Services such as mail delivery, air traffic control and Social Security payments would continue, even as national parks and Internal Revenue Service call centers would be likely to close. Even three-fourths of Obama's staff would be sent home.
Concerns that the budget impasse will hurt economic growth helped push the Standard & Poor's 500 Index to its first weekly decline since August. The index fell 0.4 percent to 1,691.75 on Sept. 27, and dropped 1.1 percent last week. The rate on 10-year Treasury notes fell three basis points to 2.62 percent.
Boehner's Choices
The final chance to avert a shutdown could come tomorrow evening, if the Senate turns down the latest House plan, as Democrats promise to do.
At that point, House Speaker John Boehner would have four main choices -- two of which avert a shutdown. He could pass the Senate bill with mostly Democratic votes or attempt a short-term funding extension to keep the government open past Oct. 1, when fiscal year 2014 begins.
The other two options lead to a shutdown. Boehner could add Obamacare provisions to the spending bill and ask the Senate to go along, or do nothing and wait to see the political fallout.
The latest House bill has some concessions from Republicans who have criticized the requirements the health-care law imposes on insurers. It would leave intact most of the law already in effect, such as requirements insurance companies cover people with pre-existing conditions and that family plans cover children up to age 26. The latest bill would allow insurers to deny abortion coverage based on religious or moral objections.
Proposed Delay
The House measure would delay a requirement for people to purchase coverage or face a penalty, and postpone the creation of marketplaces -- which are supposed to start functioning this Tuesday, Oct. 1 -- where people could shop for coverage from private insurers. Further, it would repeal the 2.3 percent medical device tax, which would increase deficits by about $29 billion during the next decade.
The House Republican leadership doesn't expect to pass a clean spending bill or have enough Republicans who would want to do that, according to a leadership aide who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss party strategy.
The House probably will amend the spending bill one more time. A likely option would eliminate the government's contribution to the health insurance of members of Congress and their staff, as a way of testing Democrats' willingness to make any change to the health law, the aide said.
'Chronic Chaos'
Republicans and Democrats began bracing for a shutdown by attempting to affix blame on the other side. It is at least the fourth time in the past three years that lawmakers have taken a budget battle to the brink of a fiscal crisis, each time averting the worst-case scenario just before or after the deadline.
"This has been the Congress of chronic chaos since day one, and this is just another episode," said Representative Steve Israel, a New York Democrat.
Boehner had attempted to avoid this fight, offering a plan earlier in September that wouldn't have tied Obamacare to the extension of government funding. Instead he wanted to have what he called a "whale of a fight" in October over raising the federal debt ceiling. That will be necessary by Oct. 31 at the latest to ensure the government has enough money to pay its bills, according to the Congressional Budget Office.
Tea Party
Tea Party-backed hardliners aligned with Republican Senator Ted Cruz rejected Boehner's plan, insisting on the decisive battle that is unfolding in the days leading up to Oct. 1, when insurance exchanges open and allow uninsured Americans to enroll for coverage in 2014.
"The American people deserve to have time to see what this monstrosity will do before it is implemented," said Representative John Culberson, a Texas Republican. "We are simply offering a compromise of a year's delay."
The vote on the one-year delay was mostly along party lines, with Democrats Mike McIntyre of North Carolina and Jim Matheson of Utah voting yes and Republicans Chris Gibson and Richard Hanna, both of New York, voting no.
Representative Michael Grimm, a New York Republican, said he expected Boehner to eventually seek Democratic votes.
"Do I think Obamacare's bad policy?" he said. "Yes, but I also think shutting down the government is bad policy. It's almost like two wrongs don't make a right. We have to get past this and govern."
Debt Ceiling
Boehner and House Majority Leader Eric Cantor of Virginia, who often rally the party on the House floor before major votes, didn't give speeches.
In addition to the Obamacare delay, the House voted 248-174 to attach the repeal of an excise tax on medical devices to the spending bill.
The continued fight over the spending bill makes the outcome of the debt-ceiling debate even less certain. Lawmakers could still be negotiating the end of this debate even as the next one looms.
In a government shutdown, essential operations and programs financed with permanent streams of money would continue. Still, a shutdown could reduce fourth-quarter economic growth by as much as 1.4 percentage points, depending on its duration, according to economists. The biggest effect would come from the output lost from furloughed workers.
The House passed a bill 423-0 early today that would make sure that U.S. troops and the civilians and contractors who support them get paid during any shutdown.
Funding Levels
Representative Jim McGovern, a Massachusetts Democrat, said Republicans wouldn't accept the victory they were getting -- keeping current funding levels under across-the-board sequestration that Democrats find unacceptable and damaging.
"I was kind of hoping the grownups in the Republican conference would prevail," McGovern said.
House Republicans have voted more than 40 times to delay, defund or repeal all or part of the 2010 health-care law, which is designed to expand coverage to at least 30 million people. Some of the narrower proposals became law. The U.S. Supreme Court upheld the law in June 2012.
The new House plan would postpone for one year a central provision of Obamacare: the requirement that almost all individuals obtain insurance.
Tax subsidies scheduled to begin Jan. 1, 2014, would start a year later. The plan would suspend some Obamacare taxes for the 2014 tax year and allow employers with religious objections to opt out of the mandate that most workplace insurance plans include contraceptive coverage.
'Not Ready'
"It's not ready," said Representative Marsha Blackburn, a Tennessee Republican. "We are seeing the impact of delay after delay that is being done by this administration, and what we are saying is it is time, as a fairness issue to the American people -- delay the whole thing."
That's different from the Republicans' initial spending bill, which passed Sept. 20 and would have choked off government funding for Obamacare. The Senate rejected that measure and passed its bill on a 54-44 party-line vote Sept. 27.
Republicans said they hoped their proposal would attract some support among Senate Democrats and bring Democrats into negotiations that they have resisted.
The Senate voted 79-20 earlier this year in support of repealing the medical device tax, and Senator Joe Manchin of West Virginia said last week that he supports a delay in the individual mandate. In a subsequent statement, Manchin said the individual mandate shouldn't be used to shut down the government.
'Pointless'
"We continue to be willing to debate these issues in a calm and rational atmosphere," Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid said in a statement that called the Republican plan "pointless." He added, "The American people will not be extorted by Tea Party anarchists."
Democrats said any changes to the health law shouldn't be made to avert a catastrophe.
"The president has shown that he is willing to improve the health-care law and meet Republicans more than halfway to deal with our fiscal challenges, but he will not do so under threats of a government shutdown that will hurt our economy," Jay Carney, the White House press secretary, said in a statement yesterday. "Any member of the Republican Party who votes for this bill is voting for a shutdown." (Bloomberg)