Apple Inc., maker of the iPad and iPhone, for the second time failed to win a ban on sales of Samsung Electronics Co.'s Galaxy 10.1N from a German court.
The Dusseldorf Regional Court rejected the bid today in a case where Apple invoked a European design right. Apple last week lost a similar attempt over a technology patent in a Munich court.
A Dusseldorf appeals court last week upheld Apple's request to ban sales of the Galaxy Tab 10.1, the predecessor model. Samsung began selling the Galaxy Tab 10.1N, a revised version, in Germany last year to get around that ban. Samsung lost two patent rulings against its rival in a Mannheim court last month.
The Galaxy Tab 10.1N now sufficiently differs from the form Apple has registered as a design right,?the court said in a statement. "You can no longer talk of a quasi-identical copy" of the iPad.
The legal battle between Cupertino, California-based Apple and its closest competitor in tablet computers is intensifying as an increasing number of consumers use tablets and smartphones to visit websites, play games and download music. More patent rulings between the two are scheduled for the coming weeks.
Samsung said the ruling affirms its position that the Galaxy Tab 10.1N is distinctive and does not infringe the rights asserted by Apple. The Galaxy Tab 10.1N remains available to consumers in Germany, Samsung said.
Apple spokesman Alan Hely didn't immediately respond to an e-mail seeking comment. (Bloomberg)
<한글기사>
삼성, 獨서 갤럭시탭 10.1N 소송 승소
아이패드와 아이폰 생산업체인 애플이 독일 법원에서 진행된 삼성전자의 태블릿PC 갤럭시탭 10.1N의 판매 금지 가처분 소송에서 패소했다고 블룸버그 통신이 9일 보도했다.
갤럭시탭 10.1N은 기존 갤럭시탭 10.1이 애플의 디자인 특허 침해 소송에서 패 소해 독일 내 판매금지 당하자 삼성이 디자인을 대폭 변경해 새로 낸 제품이다.